Hot Sex and Bad Mothers: It Must be Ayelet Waldman
An introduction, by Sarah:
Ayelet Waldman is the New York Times bestselling author of BAD MOTHER: A CHRONICLE OF MATERNAL CRIMES, MINOR CALAMITIES AND OCCASIONAL MOMENTS OF GRACE, a collection of essays exploring what it means to be a "bad mother" in today's society.
In addition, a film adaptation of her wildly successful novel, LOVE AND OTHER IMPOSSIBLE PURSUITS about a young wife who's dealing with a fresh tragedy along with a new husband whom she wed after breaking up his first marriage, is slated to premier at the Toronto Film Festival September 16th. It stars Natalie Portman and hot damn if we aren't green with envy.
But perhaps Ayelet, despite her talents and writing skills, is most famous for public comments she's made regarding the intense relationship with her husband, Pulitzer Prize winning author Michael Chabon. A mother of four, Ayelet nevertheless has declared that it is her husband for whom she yearns more than her children, that while she could survive if one of her children died before her, she questions her ability to do the same should it be Michael to pass on. If you think that's nuts, just wait to hear what she has to say about being bipolar.
It's never a dull moment when Ayelet's around. This woman has managed to turn motherhood, marriage and mental illness askew asking that we at least reconsider our entrenched notions of right and wrong before we judge. Also, she's been on Oprah. 'Nuff said.
What follows is a Q&A I did with Ayelet following the publication of BAD MOTHER. You might disagree with her, even prickle at some of her comments, but there's no getting around it: Ayelet Waldman makes great copy.
TLC: Why, especially when it comes to mothering, are women more critical of other women than men? What happened to sisterhood solidarity and all that jazz? Is this just another example of us being too catty to get along? Or are we simply really good mothers who know better than everyone else? :)
AYELELT: If I only knew the answer to that!! My husband can see a father behaving badly and perhaps even comment on it (to me, never to that dad), but that other father's behavior makes zero impression on him, on how he sees himself. I, on the other hand, see a woman doing something I'd never do (like, say, feeding her child Doritoes. Oh wait, I did that last week.) and even my condemnation is experienced through the lens of my own experience. I don't just say, "Look at that loser." I say "Look at that Bad Mother. I'd never do that." I think we condemn other mothers because we're so desperately insecure about our own mothering. We're so worried we've made mistakes, that we're doing it wrong, that our children will grow up to be serial killers or never get into Harvard (and which, by the way, is worse?), that we desperately seek out this iconic Bad Mother symbols to make ourselves feel better.
Plus, we're catty and bitchy. Which, frankly, I think is fine, as long as we do it behind one another's backs. I mean, when did flame wars become acceptable means of discourse for normal people?
TLC: Who's the better mother: An organized, if reserved and slightly cold, woman who attends all her children's sports events, never swears, puts dinner on the table promptly at 6:30 complete with low fat/high protein/rich in fruits and vegetables dinners and role models perfect behavior OR....The warm loving soul who maybe drinks a bit, has a few too many boyfriends stay on overnights, forgets that it's the day of the school concert and therefore her children do not have the requisite black pants/white shirt and tends to talk like a sailor?
Need you ask? But honestly, I'd love it if we could just back away entirely from the comparison and competition. Embracing the Bad Mother identity serves a purpose -- it relaxes us, it amuses us. But really we're still caught in the same dichotomy, we're still using the same toxic language.
TLC: Marriage. Yours, apparently, is fantastic and sex has never been better. But it seems like the only people dying to get married these days are gay. If marriage is so awesome, how come women are growing increasingly cool to the idea?
AYELET: Is this really true? I didn't know that... Maybe it's because they figure that if they're going to have to take care of the kids and the house and work for a living ANYWAY, they might as well cut down on the number of individuals they need to be taking care of? I don't know.
TLC: Did you really mean what you said about enjoying bipolarity? And just how much can you get done in a manic phase?
AYELET: I once wrote 3 novels in 7 months, how's that for awesome. I don't enjoy mania. I enjoy HYPOmania. Two very different things. Mania means you buy the entire contents of the Bloomingdale's petite section and then stop off at Hold Everything to drop 5 grand on storage boxes for your new clothes. Hypomania means you allow yourself the indulgence of a pair of YSL Tribute Sandals even though you can't afford it. Mania means you wear a tinfoil hat and draft a 3000 page document detailing your persecution at the hands of the Somali Volunteer Coastguard. Hypomania means that you finish your novel in two weeks at the MacDowell Colony.
I love hypomania. I've never been manic...I'm lucky. But I loath the irritability. I loath how scary it is for my kids that I can be so volatile. On balance, I'd rather NOT be bipolar, but no one is offering me that option. (Pfizer? You listening?).
TLC: Finally, you're a bestselling author, you're married to Michael Chabon and you two do it like seventeen times a day, live in a cool Berkeley community and are on a first-name basis with Barack Obama with whom you went to Harvard Law. Give me three good reasons why I shouldn't loathe you with every envious bone in my body.
AYELET:
1. I have this huge flap of skin that droops from hipbone to hipbone that I would love to have hacked off, but I'm afraid of going down in history as the mother so blindingly self-absorbed and vain that she left 4 motherless waifs in her quest to be thin.
2. I'm crazy. Seriously. The bipolar thing is no picnic.
3. My mysteries are fast going out of print, and yours, my dear, are selling like hotcakes.
Guess what: I'll trade a diminishing backlist for the New York Times thingy. Deal?
So what do you think? Is Ayelet nuts for declaring the virtues of mental illness? Is it wrong to love your husband more than your children? Are women REALLY harder on other women for their mothering and, if so, what happened to the notion of sisterhood? And, finally, just what the hell do I have to do to get on Oprah, anyway.
Sarah
=